ACADEMICS SUGGEST SALES BAN TO UNDER 18S

'Adolescents don't know what they're drinking': Energy drinks study warns

Daniel Jurena/Flickr

Australian academics warn that young adolescents can easily identify energy drinks brands such as Red Bull or Monster, but are unaware of key ingredients including caffeine, guarana and taurine, and in comments that should serve as a wake-up call for brands, suggest that regulations, labeling and advertising rules be tightened.

Beth Costa led the Deakin University School of Psychology focus group study, 'Young Adolescents’ Perceptions, Patterns, and Contexts of Energy Drink Use', and examined the "perceptions, patterns and contexts” of energy drink use among 40 adolescents aged 12-15 from two regional Australian schools.

In their findings, the Deakin University team said that young adolescents may use energy drinks “in a manner similar to older individuals without knowing what they are drinking and how they contribute to their personal risk of harm.”

They suggest looking at the influence of energy drinks' advertising, their appropriate labeling, and regulated sale as risk-associated products.

"Possible recommendations include restricting the sale of energy drinks to people under the age of 18, introducing clearer labeling of risk of harm to children and adolescents, as well as regulating energy drink advertisements targeting children and adolescents," Costa et al. write.

The study found that adolescents could identify energy drink brands such as Red Bull and Monster, but in many cases were unaware of key ingredients such as caffeine, glucose, guarana, taurine, and glucuronolactone.

"Participants were familiar with energy drinks and most had used them at least once but had limited knowledge of energy drink ingredients," Costa et al. wrote.

While most kids could easily identify energy drinks by brand name, there was also “some confusion particularly among the younger participants about the differences between energy drinks and other drinks.”

“These findings suggest young adolescents use energy drinks without knowing what they are drinking and how they are contributing to their personal risk of harm," Costa et al. wrote. "The advertising, appeal and use of energy drinks by adolescents appears to share similarities with alcohol and tobacco," they added.

Parents and advertising

The study, published in the journal Appetite, found that energy drink use was influenced by parenting and advertising, which "associated energy drinks with high-risk extreme behaviors that appeal to youth through non-traditional mediums (such as social media) adolescents frequently use."

Parents also "appeared to play a key role in influencing participants' use or disuse of energy drinks," the team wrote.

For younger participants, parental disapproval “appeared to prevent them from using energy drinks, while some of the older participants reported using energy drinks despite parental disapproval."

“In other cases, participants indicated that their parents condoned or encouraged their use of energy drinks at times, particularly when consumption had the functional aim of alleviating fatigue for sport and recreation," the study added.

Based on the findings of their study, the Deakin University researchers suggest tightening up regulations surrounding the availability, labeling and advertisement of energy drinks.

“The long-term harms of alcohol use by youth have only recently been adequately identified after more than 100 years of research," Costa et al. wrote. "There is a strong case for adopting the precautionary principle when it comes to young people’s health."

Source: Appetite, Available online May 20 2014, http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.appet.2014.05.013

Title: 'Young adolescents’ perceptions, patterns, and contexts of energy drink use: a focus group study'

Authors: Costa, B. Hayley, A., Miller, P.

*Check out our other special edition articles dedicated to energy drinks below!

'Up, up and beyond up!' Eye-catching energy drink launches: The BeverageDaily Top 10

Safety fears could slow energy drink drive into liquid water enhancers

Beauty meets the EU energy drinks beast…

Related News

Eye-catching energy drink launches: The BeverageDaily Top 10

'Up, up and beyond up!' Eye-catching energy drink launches: The BeverageDaily Top 10

Study: Energy drinks increase the desire to drink longer and harder

Study: Energy drinks increase the desire to drink longer and harder

Canadean: “Energising products are slowly shifting from drinks into other categories, such as food and personal care...”

Energy category brushes up against toothpaste

Mother Energy Drink: Geoff Stokes/Flickr

Coke Amatil backs Mother after mom blames energy drinks for son’s death

"Caffeinated energy drinks are a commercial product that can significantly increase sporting performance in many sports activities," says Spanish researcher.

Energy drinks increase sports performance – and insomnia and nervousness, says study

"So the resealablity is actually completely changing the dynamic because you don’t need to finish the can and take all the intake in one go,” says UK firm Grenade Energy

Down in 1 (or 2 or 3): Resealable energy drink newbie encourages ‘responsible’ consumption

"Aggressive marketing of energy drinks targeted at young people combined with limited and varied regulation has created an environment where energy drinks could pose a significant threat to public health," say researchers

Should energy drinks be age-restricted like alcohol? WHO official asks in report

Euromonitor: "...the main threat lies in the magnitude of EU countries following the lead of Lithuania‘s action."

Lithuania bans energy drink sales to under 18s

Red Bull is one of the brands criticized in the report

Energy drink companies unwilling to protect teenagers, say US senators

Single doses of caffeine up to 200mg do not raise safety concerns for adults, also when consumed less than two hours before intense exercise, says EFSA

EFSA: 400mg of caffeine a day is safe

'The 400mg [daily] upper limit should also not be understood as a green light for consuming up to five energy drinks a day,' says consumer group BEUC.

EFSA caffeine opinion is not a green light

Thought soft drinks were sugary? Look at energy drinks! says Action on Sugar

Thought soft drinks were sugary? Look at energy drinks! says Action on Sugar

Parents are giving children energy drinks at birthday parties, says Danish report

‘Energy drinks are not for children!’ says Danish campaign

Comments (2)

Eliza - 03 Jun 2014 | 04:59

Good.....,but

Good information; however the same information was repeated up to three times in this short article. It would have been great if the author actually cited the risks of the additives in the energy drinks for the readers. Basically everything that is stated in the article can be had from the title. I agree energy drinks need to regulated and persons should have to wait until the age of 18 or 21 to consume.

seonaid mackenzie - 27 May 2014 | 07:33

Teenz and Tweens energy drinks

If the movies and the TV had healthy drinks in their hands, then these young drinkers would lean towards healthy drinks but currently not so cool

Submit a comment

Your comment has been saved

Post a comment

Please note that any information that you supply is protected by our Privacy and Cookie Policy. Access to all documents and request for further information are available to all users at no costs, In order to provide you with this free service, William Reed Business Media SAS does share your information with companies that have content on this site. When you access a document or request further information from this site, your information maybe shared with the owners of that document or information.